SpaceOpera.com

Star Trek: Voyager reviews — season 1

Star Trek: Voyager — 1x02 — Caretaker, Part II

Synopsis

The crew races to save Torres and Kim.

Remarkable scenes

  • Neelix' introduction.
  • Neelix' reaction to the transporter.
  • Tuvok suggesting to Neelix that he take a bath.
  • Neelix indulging himself in his quarters.
  • Neelix annoying Tuvok.
  • Neelix' successful manipulation of the events to save Kes.
  • Janeway pulling the plug on the doctor.
  • Tuvok discovering that the caretaker is dying.
  • Paris saving Chakotay.
  • The huge Kazon ship.
  • Chakotay: "Tell one of your crackerjack Starfleet transporter chiefs to keep a lock on me!"
  • Chakotay crashing his ship into the huge Kazon vessel.
  • The Kazon ship crashing into the array.
  • The Caretaker's final words.
  • Janeway destroying the array.

Review

Following in the tradition of the first part, Neelix and Kes are introduced very nicely in this episode. I like how Chakotay and Tom have settled their differences in this episode. When Tom saves Chakotay's life and asks about the Native American tradition which would dictate Chakotay's life belonging to Tom, Chakotay says "wrong tribe." But at the end of the episode, Janeway tells Tom that Chokotay mentioned something to her about his life belonging to Tom and that he'd be responsible for Tom's safety. He lied! Very funny. The Caretaker's complete motives are finally revealed in this episode, which brings up the moral dilemma regarding whether to use the array to get home or to destroy it to protect the Ocampa. Many fans call Janeway stupid for deciding to stay in the Delta Quadrant to protect the Ocampa, even Tuvok questions the decision in this episode, as does Torres. Janeway herself will question it a few times later in the series. Personally, I wish they had handled the decision in this episode a little differently. Think about it. The Kazon are all over that array like flies on garbage and Tuvok said it would take hours to configure it to send them back. Do you really think the Kazon are going to just sit there while Janeway and Tuvok are tinkering with the array for two hours? No, I don't think so. And for this reason, I say Janeway was forced into her decision, despite the fact that it seems she would have anyway. A fantastic pilot, probably the best pilot episode of any of the series.